Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Satoru

Reconciliation :
Sword or Plowshare

default

 Asterisk (original poster member #86331) posted at 1:40 PM on Saturday, November 21st, 2026

On disclosure day, each spoken word, as my wife confessed, was stripping her and me of our dignity. I felt our marriage swirling downward as each syllable of my wife’s detailed account stripped and reshaped us. I was stunned as I quietly listened to her. I couldn’t make sense of how my sweet, loving wife, by her own hand, could flush our marriage down the toilet as if she and I was nothing more than bodily waste material.

For a time it felt as if our marriage was nothing more than a large, smelly turd stuck within the drainpipe called marriage. That stinch of that new concept of our marriage was stinking up my soul. I found myself desperately seeking fresh air. But I found myself wedged, drowning in the sewer of ruminations. It too me far too long to understand that much of the cesspool I found myself floating in was created of my own interpretations!

I had a hard decision to make. Was I going to grow empathy for my wife or use her actions to forge a sword of righteousness. Early in, I realized I now held the moral high-ground, and I could effectively use that advantage point to attack and slay every word of contrition. And it was tempting because, in my pain and anger, her explanations sounded like justifications. I could have shouted her transgressions to the world and who’d have blamed me! (Thank God I kept my mouth shut!) My wife was completely defenseless and she and I knew it!

I wanted to choose a different path. I wasn’t perfect, but I desired to look beyond the act and try to understand my wife because she had done something that was outside of "her" morality. Though I sucked at it, I needed to allow her space, time and method to discover that dark spot inside of herself that encouraged her to do something she knew was wrong. I also wanted to seek out what my role in it was.

I didn’t want to slay anyone. I didn’t want to beat down on anyone. I didn’t want revenge or punishment to befall my wife nor her affair partner. I wanted to listen to her. I wanted to be listened too. She needed space to self-inspect. (Which often means, no matter the level of pain, for trickle truth to slow until it stopped, as she regained or rebuilt her own ethics.) I needed to openly listen, especially to the painful things and allow for her reconstruction to be on her terms and timetable, not mine. At that point I could decide if I wanted to stay or leave.

I say all this because this same ability is here at SI. We, as betrayed spouses, have a unique chance to respectfully listen to wayward spouses as they disclose and reconstruct their lives. We do not need to agree with their explanations, but we might be wise to try to understand or at least give them a safe place to share. I often hear it said here at SI that we want our wayward spouses to be authentic but to do so on our terms. Puzzling?

There comes a time when one is best served to lay down the sword and beat it into plowshares.

Asterisk

posts: 545   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8909996
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 7:39 AM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

I like the journey through rediscovering your inner needs while navigating through the abyss of pain towards the shore of empathy.

I feel reservations for the leaning towards external validation of those felt feelings during the journey, though I concede it might be a shade give by the artistic choice of your prose, I like how you write, is pretty neat in painting pictures with words.

I feel the loss you get from betrayal and infidelity is a very personal one, while universally devastating the parts it destroys of one’s inner world are an individual tragedy.

And the destruction erases many things that you have built in your life, things that gives you hope and meaning to the life you are living, things to look forward to while you soldier on through hardship.

Call it dreams if you wish, because some of them are, though not just dreams it doesn’t only destroy fantasies and hopes of realizing them, it hits harder still, shattering the core pillars of your humanity.

While it kills your dreams and hopes it also murder the version of you that could bring those to fruition for you and the chosen person in your life.

Not all dreams or hope are stupid because they are made mostly of fantasy and wondering, some parts of wishing does actually make you a better person while growing up, and yes it is part of the process of creating the Ego, something that I always advice to keep in check and never let replacing the true Self at the wheel, but the same process of desire, wish and hopes that gives you those life goals called dreams, is often what set a path to greatness.

When you achieve something great is usually the epitome of a long and ungrateful journey towards a goal, a goal you dreamed of long time ago, and that you pursued relentlessly through innumerable hardships and delusions.


Infidelity Kaminski the other things it destroys, kills that version of you forever.

And yes there is always a positive flip side of any coin, you do become stronger and more resilient if you manage to survive infidelity and not be doomed to be broken for the rest of your life.
You become grounded, stronger in any sense as you accept reality for what it is.

It has many benefits and advantages and it’s worth its weight in gold for you are as unbreakable as a creature capable of feeling has any right to ever become.

On the other hand, you lose the ability to make dreams come true and achieve them with greatness through hardships.
Because Humans don’t persevere through such crap if they are pragmatic.
Not for hope and dreams, for survival maybe, but dreams are let go.

That is a part of you infidelity kills that is never coming back.

And while it gets praised (rightfully so, for the reasons above) all the positives acquired from letting go of that "naivity" which are undoubted, you suffered a loss of that part of you that was driven towards realizing dreams.

Not the little ones that can be planned practically, the big ones that are life defining for a living person.

That very pure and spiritual part of your nature, your history, your spiritual identity if you wish, is taken forever away from you by the closest person you have and their affair partner.

It is dead, not coming back ever, and you have all rights to mourn it because it is a loss only you will ever understand, because while it was just a chance for you to aim for and bring into fruition, you knew you could do it, and once reached it would become reality for not just you but the others as well.

So you are the only one who will ever miss it, that inner death is an abortion of your potential that only you will ever miss, killed by illusion delusion and cruelty.

You will be more efficient in getting by without that side of you, because you are focused.
And maybe to many your lost dreams may feel stupid, unreachable or just too small to be missed.

That’s irrelevant for it is your loss, of dreams, of potential of goals that might have turned out far greater than you would ever realize, as it often happens when you out all yourself, are your qualities into something.

No matter how "small" this might be looking to me (as an external observer) for the person who wished it it meant the world for their life, and I learned it is usually the kind of things that when you meet make the world a richer place.

And now it is forever poorer for it was taken away by two broken people.
Buried in the fields of broken dreams for eternity.

It doesn’t kill you, it makes you stronger, still not everything that hardens you makes you and others reacher.

It’s a loss with mourning for.

Maybe you can forge a plowshares, but it is more made from the shovel you used to bury the corpse of your "inner child" than a sword.

It is a victim than no one else but you will ever care to spare a second for, unless they get it.

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1272   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8910014
default

Pogre ( member #86173) posted at 12:18 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

It's a difficult and fine line to walk. I did develop empathy and sympathy for my wife early on. Our marriage was nit ideal for a long time, butnthings had started improving between us in the couple of years leading up to her affair, so I was quite blindsided.

We've have many conversations about that. A pretty long and in depth one on Friday in fact, while we went on a long walk. We had gotten into an argument about hair conditioner that blew up into something entirely different. I put together something in writing to read to her.


Something I want you to understand about where I am right now

I want to explain what's been going on with me today, because I don't think it's just about the argument we had over conditioner.

That argument brought up a much bigger feeling that I've been carrying for a long time: frustration, disappointment, and sometimes a sense of hopelessness when I feel like something has been discussed, understood, agreed upon, and then eventually goes right back to the way it was. I've spent a lot of time trying to explain things clearly, find ways to make them easier to understand, and work through disagreements with you. So when something happens that makes it feel as though all of that effort has disappeared, it can hit me pretty hard.

But I also recognize that the conditioner issue and the affair are not the same thing. I'm not saying that using too much conditioner is equivalent to betraying our marriage. It isn't. What happened today simply stirred up some of the frustration and resentment I still have about the affair and, especially, what happened afterward.

And that's where a lot of my anger is coming from.

The affair itself was devastating. But the way things unfolded after I found out added another layer of hurt. There was the lying, the minimizing, the continued contact, the defensiveness, the way you sometimes defended him, and the things you said to other people while I was being given a different picture of what was happening. There were times when I felt that you were more concerned with protecting yourself, or even protecting him, than with understanding what you had done to me.

I shouldn't have had to dig through messages and piece things together to understand what was happening. I shouldn't have had to keep pushing for honesty. And I certainly shouldn't have had to fight for empathy from the person who had hurt me.

One thing that was particularly painful was hearing you say, when I criticized him for pursuing a married woman, that it wasn't all him, that you were willing too. I understand what you meant. You were acknowledging your own responsibility, and you were right to do that. But in that moment, I wasn't asking you to remind me that you had willingly participated. I already knew that. I was hurting, and hearing you emphasize your willingness felt like another painful reminder rather than an acknowledgment of what I was going through.

I don't want you to misunderstand me. I believe you have made real progress. I believe you recognize that what you did was wrong. I believe you feel genuinely awful about the affair and about how you treated me afterward. I see the changes in your behavior, the affection, the closeness, and the effort you've made toward our marriage. I don't dismiss any of that.

But there's something I still struggle with.

When you apologize, it's often something along the lines of, "I know I hurt you. I'm sorry for hurting you." I believe you mean it. I'm not necessarily questioning your sincerity. But those words are general, and the things that happened to me weren't general. They were specific experiences, specific betrayals, and specific moments when I needed you and felt abandoned by you.

What I want is to know that you understand those individual experiences, not just that you understand the overall conclusion that you hurt me.

For example, you've brought up leaving me on the side of the road and said that you feel awful about it and can only imagine how that made me feel. That means something to me. But we've talked about that incident many times. You know how painful it was for me.

What I'm still looking for is more evidence that you think about the other things yourself, without me having to bring them up first. Do you ever independently think about the times you defended AP? The times you continued communicating with him after I found out? The things you said to friends? The dishonesty and minimizing? Do you think about what those experiences were like for me, and what they did to my ability to trust you?

There's a difference between responding when I remind you that something hurt me and independently recognizing that you did something hurtful.

I'm not asking you to memorize a list of offenses or give me a perfectly worded apology. I'm not asking you to repeat something just because you think it's what I want to hear. I want to know that you've actually thought about these things, that you've considered what they were like from my side, and that you can recognize the damage without needing me to explain it all over again.

I also understand that putting complicated feelings into words isn't always easy for you. I know you sometimes struggle to explain what you're thinking, and I don't want to mistake difficulty expressing something for an absence of feeling. But I don't want that difficulty to become a reason we never get to the deeper understanding, either.

I have spent a tremendous amount of time trying to help you understand what happened, why it hurt, and how your behavior affected me. I don't regret trying to communicate with you. But I don't want to be the only one doing the work of revisiting the past and recognizing what happened.

I want to see you take some initiative in that process.

And I need you to understand why I still have doubts sometimes. You lied to me. You withheld information. You denied things that eventually turned out to be true. I spent a long time not knowing whether what you were telling me was the whole truth. That doesn't automatically mean there's more you're hiding, and I don't want to treat suspicion as proof. But it does mean that trust isn't something I can simply switch back on because things are good between us now.

I'm trying to build that trust again. Your behavior today matters, and so does your behavior over the past year and a half. I see it. But the history matters, too. Both things can be true: you can be making genuine changes now, and I can still be carrying considerable hurt from what happened before.

I don't want to live in the past. I don't want every disagreement to become an argument about the affair. I want the marriage we're building now. I enjoy being close to you. I enjoy the affection and intimacy we've regained. I value the relationship we have today.

But I can't pretend the past didn't happen just because the present is better.

What I need most isn't another general apology or another promise that things will be different. I need to feel that you understand what you did, including the ways you made an already terrible situation worse after discovery. I need to see that understanding reflected not only in how you respond when I bring something up, but in what you recognize and acknowledge on your own.

I don't expect you to fix everything today. I don't expect perfect words. And I'm not telling you this because I want you to feel terrible or because I want to punish you.

I'm telling you because I want you to understand where I am. I want us to keep moving forward, but I need to feel that we're both doing the work of understanding what happened, not just trying to get past it.

I love you, and I believe in the progress we've made. I just need you to understand that there is still some hurt here that hasn't completely healed. And sometimes, when something else goes wrong, it brings that hurt right back to the surface.

She has some cognitive and comprehension issues due her her TBI and the resulting epilepsy it caused when she was an infant.

I explained that the affair wasn't just one big event that devastated me. It was devastation on top of devastation on top of devastation as I continued uncovering more withheld info and lies during that first month until I couldn't take it anymore and started calling divorce lawyers right in front of her.

She revealed that she recognizes now that things weren't as bad as she'd made them in her head leading up to her affair. She had held onto resentment from years previous and failed to recognize that I had spent the 2 years or so leading up to her affair reaching back toward her and the marriage.

I wasn't Mr lovey dovey quite yet. Her prickly behavior over her driving suspension made that difficult, but as I recovered from side effects from the medication I had been on for years I was slowly returning to myself, becoming more involved and doing many things that showed I did still care for her. She was so wrapped up in resentment over the driving issue that she didn't even see it.

It was a great talk and she's working even harder now to provide more of what I asked for. I'm glad we had it.

Where am I going... and why am I in this handbasket?

posts: 1136   ·   registered: May. 18th, 2025   ·   location: Arizona
id 8910021
default

 Asterisk (original poster member #86331) posted at 1:21 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

. BackFromTheStorm,

This is a powerful response, and I need time to dissect it. In many ways I wish it were its own post. Not that I do not value it as an insightful reply to my post, but that I fear it will be missed by others who do not read my posts or comments on them. It is going to take me a while, but I will respond in more detail in a bit. That said, I did want to highlight this:

Maybe you can forge a plowshares, but it is more made from the shovel you used to bury the corpse of your "inner child" than a sword.


A "shovel" verses a "sword", used to "bury" verses "slay". I thought that was a very interesting and insightful tweak, that may very well be closer to the truth than I would like to admit. I will confess, in the 1st 10 years, for a variety of reasons I purposely bury stuff, some call it "rug sweeping". I would argue it was less about rug sweeping and more along the line, as you stated, burying it. It is much easier to pick up the edges of an area rug and clean the dirt off an otherwise clean and protected floor than it is to dig deep into the dirt and separate the soil from the soiled.

Either way, I maintain whether shovel or sword, there comes a time in the recovery process, especially important in reconciliation, to beat the hardened metal into plowshares.

More later, I need to drink some coffee and wake up my brain. (True be known, I don’t drink coffee, tomato juice is my morning sip, but who wakes up with juice?)

Asterisk

posts: 545   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8910024
default

 Asterisk (original poster member #86331) posted at 1:24 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

Pogre,

I have spent a tremendous amount of time trying to help you understand what happened, why it hurt, and how your behavior affected me. I don't regret trying to communicate with you. But I don't want to be the only one doing the work of revisiting the past and recognizing what happened.
I want to see you take some initiative in that process.


The above quote hits a tender spot. I have pleaded for 35 years with my wife to please, sometimes be the one to bring up the subject. As amazing and caring my wife is, she has not been able to do so. I have tried to explain to her that making me the one to always bring it up makes me the "bad gay" who cannot "get over it". I am aware that she doesn’t do this out of malice, and that understanding helps, but I still feel like a jerk or the only one that reflects on the affair days.

Thank you for sharing the letter you wrote your wife after the "conditioner" issue. It is a great reminder how an unrelated, relatively minor issue can quickly spiral into a tornado event. That was great insight on your part.

It was a great talk and she's working even harder now to provide more of what I asked for. I'm glad we had it.


It is wonderful to read that there was a positive outcome.

Asterisk

posts: 545   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8910025
default

Pogre ( member #86173) posted at 2:04 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

The above quote hits a tender spot. I have pleaded for 35 years with my wife to please, sometimes be the one to bring up the subject. As amazing and caring my wife is, she has not been able to do so. I have tried to explain to her that making me the one to always bring it up makes me the "bad gay" who cannot "get over it". I am aware that she doesn’t do this out of malice, and that understanding helps, but I still feel like a jerk or the only one that reflects on the affair days.

Yesterday when we were sitting on the couch she brought something up without prompting. A specific lie, the cover story she used for her first tryst.

She said that she feels awful for that day. That lie. That she knew she was lying to me and I was clueless as to what she was really doing, and the fact that I offered her a lift (which she turned down for obvious reasons) made her feel even worse.

She then apologized profusely for it and said that she can only imagine how betrayed I felt when I learned the truth.

That's a tip of the iceberg thing to bring up, but the fact that she brought it up on her own told me that she does think about this stuff. I hope it continues because it did mean a lot to me. She heard me, and that means a lot.

[This message edited by Pogre at 2:10 PM, Sunday, November 22nd]

Where am I going... and why am I in this handbasket?

posts: 1136   ·   registered: May. 18th, 2025   ·   location: Arizona
id 8910028
default

Bigger ( Attaché #8354) posted at 2:31 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

Some of us might be old enough to remember when a leader for one group/nation signed a peace treaty with another leader of a group/nation in an attempt to end a long-going conflict. When asked how he felt about making a peace-treaty with a person he had deep hate for, he said something like You don't make peace with friends. You make it with very unsavory enemies"
(Hope that is written opaque enough to pass our strict NO POLITICS rule…)

I think this might be the toughest part about early reconciliation. You are trying to be positive about the person that cause the most negative situation you have ever dealt with. It’s like trying to pet a dog that has repeatedly bitten you.

One method/tip that could help is if you can view your spouse as two different people: The WS and the RS (reconciling spouse). You hate the WS and are seeking the RS. Just like we can sway between wanting to R and having doubts, the RS can sway between honestly working at R and leaning towards the WS behaviors.
Those WS behaviors can have different levels of damage. None acceptable, none sustainable to reach R, but of various grades of impact on R. For example; realizing the WS is still hooking up with the AP is a definite serious impact on the will to R. The WS checking the social media of the AP is bad, but less serious. Trickle-truthing about the level of sex is serious, not remembering to tell they ate at a certain restaurant maybe not so much.

I think it’s not sensible to put the task of reconciling totally into the hands of the WS. We – the BS need to be "project managers", keeping in mind that sometimes a project manager needs to make the call that the project is doomed. At the same time we need to deal with our personal healing, and the healing of the relationship. It’s normal that at times we look at the WS with hate, but at the same time need the WS to have a shoulder to cry on.
Having some capability of viewing them as the WS and the RS, and then remembering why we are still where we are (by our own decision) can help. Our goal then is that in the WS – through repeated behavior, verification and actions – the RS becomes the dominant person.

"If, therefore, any be unhappy, let him remember that he is unhappy by reason of himself alone." Epictetus

posts: 14179   ·   registered: Sep. 29th, 2005
id 8910029
default

NotMyIdentity ( member #87565) posted at 6:41 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

I appreciate this perspective. I think there's a bit of a contradiction in encouraging someone to work on themselves and become healthier, but then being uncomfortable when that growth means they develop boundaries, recognize their own needs, or become more comfortable disagreeing. Sometimes disagreement is just disagreement. It doesn't automatically mean avoidance or a lack of remorse.

I also think there's a difference between having a say in what you need from reconciliation and positioning yourself as the person who gets to direct the other person's recovery. I understand wanting some control after being hurt, but I'm not sure that dynamic is healthy or sustainable for either person. There's a difference between holding someone accountable and managing them.

I don't think it's particularly helpful to separate the person who betrayed from the person who's now reconciling. We're one and the same. We have to own our choices and their consequences, but we're also allowed to grow beyond them.

And that doesn't mean we stop being individuals with our own preferences, wants, and needs. Those don't disappear because we've hurt someone.

Personally, I think making room for both of us to be individuals, even when we don't always agree, is a big part of why my spouse and I are doing well. We can take responsibility for the past while still building a relationship that belongs to both of us.

posts: 99   ·   registered: Jul. 11th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8910032
default

LonelyGuilty ( member #87155) posted at 10:09 PM on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

Asterisk, I find your posts always insightful and close to "home".

I had a hard decision to make. Was I going to grow empathy for my wife or use her actions to forge a sword of righteousness. Early in, I realized I now held the moral high-ground, and I could effectively use that advantage point to attack and slay every word of contrition. And it was tempting

As a wayward, I realised that as well. And the above is mainly why I don't (try not to) argue anymore (unless I am really pushed into a corner) with my BS. Even when the matter is not strictly related to infidelity, I know that the card is always on the table and could be easily, EASILY, used to shut me up any moment. Even in a mundane disagreement, e.g. a WS says "you said you were taking out the trash and you didn't", the BS can reply "well, I did not take out the trash, but at least I didn't cheat".

I am not saying my BS behaves necessarily like this, but I find this a complex thing to navigate.

I often hear it said here at SI that we want our wayward spouses to be authentic but to do so on our terms. Puzzling?

Obviously things are way more nuanced than I am able to write, but I can say that, for me, I have accepted that what matters is the goal. I wish to reconcile. So if this paradox (being authentic but on someone else's terms) is what is needed, I will try to get along with that and to reconcile these two aspects.

Pogre, you said something in your comment that is my final barrier to let completely go of all resentment (I probably let go of 80% of resentment).

She revealed that she recognizes now that things weren't as bad as she'd made them in her head leading up to her affair. She had held onto resentment from years previous and failed to recognize that I had spent the 2 years or so leading up to her affair reaching back toward her and the marriage.

The above could be my BS and I (although shorter timescales). But what is the truth? Were things really not that bad or they were BUT didn't justify infidelity?

In my case, things weren't as bad as I made them that could "cause" / "justify" / "be deserving" of an A. I fully recognise that. My H didn't deserve AT ALL what I did. Regardless of the things, I should never have cheated.

And I had grown resentful. Resentment was a real issue of mine (and mine to resolve).

But in this past year (1 year out from DDay), the "bad things" I perceived in the marriage went from receiving an initial empathy to be highly undermined / minimised. And I am triggered by that, because if marriage problems and infidelity are two separate things, there shouldn't be an unconscious requirement to minimise the marriage problems.

I am not saying you / any BS actively minimise those. But why, at some point, a wayward must somehow admit that their pain / unhappiness / whatever / wasn't really that bad? I totally accept and believe that infidelity is the sole responsibility of the wayward. But that doesn't mean that the wayward was necessarily making things worse than they were. Maybe in some cases, maybe in many cases they used those problems to justify the affair (and here I agree, nothing justify an affair. If things are so bad, one could D).

But I feel that having a wayward admitting that, all in all, they were just bad spouses that cheated and their problems weren't even that bad, it's just a subtle veil of punishment. "You cheated, you are flawed (100% fair) and FURTHER your pain / the issues you felt weren't even that real".

Just to clarify, this is not an attack to anyone and I apologise if I sound blunt / upset. It's just a point I am trying to understand better and where I have been genuinely stuck for a while. So I truly welcome an input on that.

NotMyIdentity: needless to say, I really felt your comment.

[This message edited by LonelyGuilty at 10:18 PM, Sunday, November 22nd]

WW

DDay Oct 25 - Trickle truth until beginning of April 26

Final DDay (all out) 14 Apr 26

posts: 127   ·   registered: Mar. 18th, 2026
id 8910035
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy